Tag Archives: Comic Review

Comic Review: Batgirl #1 (DC Comics)

Batgirl 1 cover

Batgirl could be the most controversial of the new 52 titles as Barbara Gordon has been paralysed and in a wheel chair since meeting the Joker in The Killing Joke. And since then she has evolved into the Oracle and appeared in Birds of Prey. But as The New 52 are shaking up the status quo Barbara Gordon can walk again.

Though the method of her healing isn’t yet revealed its impact is. Simone handles this change with openness and candour whilst Batgirl saves a family from the clutches of some scary killers. Though Simone turns table on her next intervention and it’s that consequence I fell that is going to be explored a little more. Someone has a list and Gordon’s name is one it and she seems to be doing pretty well working through it.

What is nice is that we see Barbara Gordon as well as Batgirl and each has a set of problems to overcome. Now her psychological as well as domestic troubles will influence her role as Batgirl an vice versa. It’s going to be interesting to see where Simone is going to take that split.

Art wise can’t fault it though it does seem quite nicely centred on giving visual signals that the text can’t with lots of shock and distress on the characters faces.

I wouldn’t call it a depressing read as it feels quite like but there is a definite darkness which is quite fitting for someone with the mantle of the Bat.

Saying all that I’m not sure if I’ll read the next one. Nothing against the character or the book. It’s more me and ‘the crime fighting’ darkness that I have a feeling is coming.

Bought on the DC Comics iPad app.

Review: Stormwatch Issue 1 (DC Comics)

52stormwatch1

Part of the reason for me trying ‘The New 52’ is to try something different and last week saw the first major release of titles after the solitary arrival of Justice League (reviewed by me here). Now Justice League was familiar in terms of character personalities and in some ways how they’d react to each other. While enjoyable it wasn’t exactly new.

On the other hand I know little to zero about what makes up Stormwatch.  And I’m not really sure what to expect. Apart from the Martian Manhunter who ended up surprising and scaring me a little at one pivotal point as well as touching on the differences in his role here and in Justice League. Luckily it’s a fun mix of confusion and introduction.

They are looking for a new recruit who definitely doesn’t want to join. And they have interesting methods of persuasion. It makes a great form of introduction to some of the cast members of Stormwatch, some of whom have odd powers if you ask me but they seem to work for them and work in the story, which is quite refreshing.

Cornell lays other seeds such as something odd is going on on the moon, especially as you get a really close and disturbing insight into it, and flashback to Storwatches past to show that their history isn’t getting totally rewritten perhaps or at least to show their longevity. Oh, not to mention that something very odd is happening in the Himalayas

For the limited number of pages available (and I will stop brining this up I promise) it feels like it’s just got going without a feeling like being shortchanged. In fact Cornell manages to do more with his pages than the Justice League team did with theirs.

I don’t know if covers are that important in comics, they don’t work as newspaper front pages, though they often contain stunning art, they don’t usually add to the story but the trio on the cover on show here definitely isn’t the current status quo.

Though in contrast this feels darker and more adult and the art reflects that. Apart from the snow scenes. If I’m 100% honest the art is a little too murky for my tastes though it’s not the line art more the computerised shadowing that gives it a that not quite classic comic book feel that I enjoy.

More than enough interest in both characters and story potential to come back to Stormwatch for more next month.

I bought and read this on the DC Comics iPad app

Comic Review: Justic League #1 (DC Comics)

Justice league 1 full

Reboot? Jumping on point? Issue 1? Or just another confusing byway in the DC timeline?

What the New 52 promises is rebalancing of the status quo to allow the core of the characters to evolve start from scratch.

So do we get that?

Yes we do.

Does it work?

You know what it does to a certain extent. What limits it more than anything else is comic book format. I’m not sure why DC hasn’t chosen to do have double issues to get new readers properly hooked.

Don’t get me wrong I’m happy going to buy the next one most to see how the dynamics of egos works out.

The ego on show is Green Lantern’s (and I’m wondering if that’ll be reflected in his own title, I guess so) and I think he’s a bit surprised to come up with such strong personalities as Batman and Superman’s.

The main thrust of the story is interesting, especially the puzzle-box element. It’s also good to see the lack of public trust.

Art wise. The panels are outstanding and stand up to the zooming on the panel-by-panel view. I’m surprised by the level of control in the Green Lantern when you see what he’s doing with the ring. They feel dynamic and capture the action with a few great flowing touches.

Didn’t really get going but money well spent so far. Looking forward to meeting other members of the League next issue.

I bought and read this on the DC Comics iPad app

Comic Review: Generation Hope #10 Marvel Comics

Generation Hope 10

As I mentioned in my review of X-Men Schism #3 I finally clicked who the youngsters were who appeared in several scenes due to the link with this issue. My curiosity got the better of me as I was wondering what I was missing so I bought this issue. Now that I know, well, meh.

It’s great comic if you’ve kept a keen eye on the X-Men I’m sure especially you get to see more from the exhibitions in the Mutant History Museum and we get to see what made Idie enter the fight in Schism #3.It also explores the dynamic of Generation Hope and how the work as a team.

The art by Tim Seeley is great as is his ability to capture facial expressions and mannerisms. The panel layout is coherent as is the dialogue.

But as enjoyable as the whole thing could be I really don’t fancy committing whole heartedly to X-Universe and all it’s interweaving connections right now.

 

Review: X-Men Schism #3 of 5 (Marvel Comics)

X men schism issue 3

Right, I’ve concluded that this isn’t a ‘jumping on’ point for the X-Men. Not that it’s being sold like that but I’ve just figured out who all those youngsters are that wondering around and that’s only due to the link it has with Generation Hope ergo the youngsters are the ‘team’ of that title.

Speaking of children we get a clearer insight into the new Hellfire Club. And there exploitation of the X-Men’s individual weaknesses. Though it does make me think why no one has thought of this tactic before (maybe they have and I’ve not been around to see it).

A couple of questions come to mind including an object that there is one of suddenly multiplying. Why Wolverine so protective of Idie? is another. Plus when did Wolverine become think first and Scott become so mission over people focused?

Another think that is slowly starting to bug my that’s £2.99 for 25 pages with 22 pages of actual story. Is it just me that finds that pricey?

Overall this is turning into a slightly more confusing tale than expected. It’s a story talking to itself if that makes sense. And after this mornings post I’m wondering if it’s worth continuing?

Comic Review: X-Men Schism #2 of 5 (Marvel)

Xmen schism 2 1

The trouble with Marvel seemingly releasing digital editions at random is I’m not quite sure when to look for the next book. I assume they are releasing these at once a month. I’m sure it’ll settle down. But it’s not helping a sense of rhythm.

Anyway, leading straight into the aftermath of last issue in X-Men Schism #2 we have Sentinels coming online all over the globe and a mix of mutants and other super heroes.

Some slightly random observations I have no idea who the kids in the school currently are or what powers they possess. There is some connection to Idie and and Wolverine.  Cyclops has aged. If you’ve seen X-Men First Class the Hellfire club has been altered beyond all recognition though I’d place money on the new person in charge being a mutant. I’ve never seen a girl go to quite the extremes one character does over a ‘kitty’. I enjoyed the idea of the current events  trending on twitter.  I’ve never quite seen Namor as an x-man.

Frank Cho’s artwork is really excellent. Especially the panels show over events around the world with Jason Arron’s dialogue make a good combination. Some of the personal choices look a little strange like Colossus’s teeth. But there is no arguing that we’re seeing a team on their game.

The pressure in the story is mounting quickly and it feels like there is a still a lot yet to be revealed. One interesting change in the dynamic I mentioned is the collaboration between the other heroes and the mutants but the low numbers of mutants seems to be creating a survive first and then fight each other second vibe. I could be calling that wrong but it makes sense.

I bought this on release so I assume I’ll have to wait a full month for the next one. Beats a year between books I guess.