I have just finished The Burning God by R.F. Kuang. It’s the last book in The Poppy War trilogy. And I have thoughts.
Currently, my thoughts centre around grimdark not being a genre I enjoy. I didn’t know that’s what The Poppy War was going to be when I went in. I just knew that a lot people on BookTok love it. And I was curious enough to pick up the series*.
Don’t get me wrong the trilogy is outstanding, challenging, thought provoking, and emotive but it lives up to the definitions of Grimdark presented on Wikipedia
Dr. Liz Bourke in her review of THE DARK DEFILES BY RICHARD MORGAN is used here:
Liz Bourke considered grimdark’s defining characteristic to be grimdark’s defining characteristic to be “a retreat into the valorisation of darkness for darkness’s sake, into a kind of nihilism that portrays right action … as either impossible or futile”Wikipedia’s Grimdark entry
And there is a quote from page 42 of Adam Roberts’s Get Started in: Writing Science Fiction and Fantasy:
“where nobody is honourable and Might is Right” and as “the standard way of referring to fantasies that turn their backs on the more uplifting, Pre-Raphaelite visions of idealized medievaliana, and instead stress how nasty, brutish, short and, er, dark life back then ‘really’ was”Wikipedia’s Grimdark entry
I didn’t know that A Land Fit for Heroes was considered grimdark…at least when I read (OK…listened to the audiobook) it didn’t strike me as darkness for darkness sake.
But The Poppy War is a brutal story. And I think it falls with the definition provided by Adam Roberts.
It’s relentless. The main character’s arc is extreme. She does terrible things and has terrible things done to her. And Kuang is great because when you reach the point that you can’t take any more, she shifts gears and the story moves along.
But I don’t think it’s a style of story I’d want to pick up regularly. I read to escape the darkness and find hope.
That’s not the point or aim of grimdark as I understand it. And The Poppy War is an exemplary example of the genre.
I don’t plan on going back to grimdark consciously, at least not for a while, unless I read a series that is grimdark but I don’t realise it is.
I’m though going to read Babel as I’m curious what Kuang will bring to dark academia… Maybe I’m a fool as I have a feeling it’ll be a dark tale…
*I read the first two books back in April and May of 2022 before picking up The Burning God in December.